Je suis toujours Charlie

“Without the freedom to criticize, there is no true praise”
Pierre-Augustin Caron de Beaumarchais (1732-1799)
Last year France was left shattered in the aftermath of the attacks against Charlie Hebdo. While French people sought comfort in Paris street, citizens from all over the world showed their support to us. In Berlin, expats founds their embassy to be a place of solace, where we were supported in our mourning by countless of kind souls.
A year on, and at a time when people are left starving to death, being bombed, massacred, and raped there not only in Syria but also in many other countries, some might not understand why France stands for its pencils.
Yet our freedom of speech is what prevents, and will prevail over, barbarism and terror.
A year ago, a bunch of happy people who just wanted to make other human beings laugh, on ANY subject, not only on religion, and on ANY religion, for that matter, not only on Islam, were massacred in a country that was once that of Enlightenment and of freedom of speech. Their lives don’t count more than the thousand lives lost in Syria. Nevertheless, they count, both because they also deserve to be considered as victims of terror and because they stood against all that terrorism embodies. Killing one of them is killing any of us who support freedom in all its forms.
By killing journalists, terrorists expected more fear. My answer is more empathy for their victims, whom I’m trying to help every day. Because I am convinced humanity will prevail.
I am still Charlie. But I am also and more importantly a citizen of the world.
Here is what I had posted elsewhere on January the 11th, 2015, after the attacks. I share it again, because I believe more than ever in values of Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity, and because no matter how many January 7th or November 13th there will be, people will stand against obscurantism.

Living history – We care.




These past few days have been unexpected in a lot of ways. No one expected to go through so many emotions – shock, sadness, disbelief, disgust, anger…What struck me the most was that instantly, people stood up together, regardless of religion, nationality, ethnicity, in an upsurge of solidarity that I never witnessed before.

We, everywhere in the world, all stood as one to protest against the actions of a minority trying to deprive us of our freedom of speech. All prejudices and differences seemed to have instantly disappeared in the aftermath of the attacks. People felt in their flesh that it was time to address problems that have been plaguing our country and society for decades now.

Suddenly, there was a feeling that there couldn’t be any democracy without freedom of speech. But there is no democracy for everyone where lies racism, xenophobia, intolerance or anti-Semitism either.





In the aftermath of the attacks, I had interesting conversations with fellow expats – French nationals and others. French people were naturally shocked. But what struck me was the reaction of others. It was sad, they felt sorry for me, but they didn’t seem to quite understand why this single event found such a resonance worldwide.

Indeed, in December, terrorists killed more than 150 children in a school in Pakistan. How many people were in the Western world’s streets by then? This is also a question we have to address. Beyond the symbolism of freedom of speech, which triggered indignation against the Paris attacks worldwide, we – us and our governments – need to rethink the way we approach global politics.

We need to value human beings no matter where they live. We need to take terrorists attacks seriously no matter where they strike, no matter who dies. We need to do more, to engage more means where possible, to fight obscurantism by development, education, culture. But we need to do so with a spirit of mutual respect and give up western paternalism towards other cultures.



So why should be we take action only now? Cynics worldwide warn that Je Suis Charlie will only be a bonfire. But because of what freedom of speech, and journalism, represent, we need to carry on what begun after the attacks. We need to nurture this determination to change things.

It doesn’t matter whether one agrees with Charlie’s editorial line or not – the fact is there is no democracy without freedom of speech. That is why people of France – and across the world – feel so strongly about that particular event. There is no liberty where there is no freedom of thought. However, now we must also learn to really live together, not as neighbours ignoring each other, but as a melting pot of cultures sharing the same values: liberty, equality, fraternity.




It is time now to realize that we need to change something inside our society. What is sad is that it took that terrible event to happen for people to be aware of it. Now that passiveness gave way to a feeling of belonging, a sense of common duty, it is time to rekindle our society and to really work on living together, side by side, regardless of beliefs or origins.

It is time to face what some tried to overlook: France is multifaceted: multiracial, multicultural. It is time to break the suburbs belts around big cities, and to engage in dialogue between rough neighbourhoods and bourgeois suburbs.

It is time to stop being afraid of someone who looks different. It is time to shake hands, to look the other in the eyes and embrace our differences. It is time to develop intercultural dialogue and reach out.

Today, in Berlin, before the Charlie gathering, I went to five different mosques. I overcame the fear I had to be rejected, insulted, or despised because I was different. I wanted to understand, as an atheist, my neighbours, and to stop just cohabiting with them. I was welcomed by every person I met. All condemned what happened in Paris.

Are we more divided now? More than ever, these terror attacks made me want to reach out people who think differently. Terrorists didn’t make me more fearful of others. We fear what we don’t know. We fear emptiness, doubt, differences, we fear what we can’t fathom. But together, we stand as one.


Thank you



On a personal level, I would like to thank all of you who cared. Your kind messages, calls, words and hugs meant a lot, and I know every French person felt the same about such reactions.

Thanks to your words I felt sheltered, protected from these atrocities by the knowledge that beyond all this there is civilization, built on love, trust, and tolerance.

I left my country because its politics and people were making me sad. I couldn’t stand its apathy anymore. In the aftermath of these attacks, out of all this darkness, France stood up again into light, with the beautiful, unconditional and international support we’ve seen.

I hope with all my heart that we only saw the beginning of a civil awakening, an awareness that our democracy belongs to us and that we are all its agents.

Charlie, what happened was such a waste. But something good will come out of it, because today we showed the world we cared.


2 thoughts on “Je suis toujours Charlie

  1. Bonjour de Paris ! ( I’ll try to write my commentary in English ) et Meilleurs Voeux pour 2016 .

    Well interesting point of view as far as various behaviours depending on the country events take place are concerned . I totally agree and it’s a very question !
    It’s absolutely true that we have got messages of supporting people from a lot of places in the World but I must mention I get some more from England and Germany .
    From South countries , the messages mainly asked : are you or any relation of yours still alive ? Not exactly the question of attacking on the Freedom itself , but attacking close friends .

    As concerns liberty , I believe it’s not only a question of free speech , but of free access to …free Education , free access to …free Wealth and cares etc …and even being free not to be a jobless .
    Thus we are not exactly as free as we aim to be .
    Moreover , who is allowed to speak on TV and Radio Channels ? who gets this possibility ? Very few people .
    Then , mostly rather rich people indeed . There is no equality in terms of free access to wide audience in our countries .

    But now , we can ask why this paradoxal reaction of our government ?
    They said the our Freedom and “laïcité” were attacked by enemies of Democracy .
    OK , but why do they decide to break our Constitution and create and vote so fast new laws that limit our own Freedom ? We were not allowed to demonstrate .
    But a few day after Charlie , we would !

    Then why Police is now allowed ( without the duty of asking a judge !) , in the state of emergency and for ever , to enter our Private life ?

    Many Black people I know have been arrested ,whereas a few years ago , Valls was called a racist because Black people were often arrested than White people …
    This is the fact . there is harrassment toward Black people in the Airport , Railways station …
    Unionist have been arrested too , whereas big boss are free to make redundant as many employees ans engineers as they want .

    Apart from that :
    Why we never take measures against the obvious increasing of fascism in Europ ?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s